![]() |
Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico,
travelling as an ordinary passenger on a commercial flight to China.
Claudia Sheinbaum, aged 64, travelled
approximately 21 hours in economy class aboard a China Southern Airlines
commercial flight, via Tijuana, to attend the APEC Summit in Shenzhen in
November 2026.
Her journey became a sensation on Chinese social media, with many praising her apparent lack of pretension and willingness to travel alongside ordinary passengers.
Sheinbaum has been President of Mexico
since October 2024.
For overseas trips, travelling on commercial airlines, including economy class, has been her usual practice, although not an absolute rule for all official travel.
There is one important qualification: she has acknowledged using Mexican military aircraft for some domestic trips, particularly when visiting several locations within a short period.
Her travel practices are also part of a broader tradition of government austerity promoted by her predecessor, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, who sold Mexico's presidential Boeing 787 in 2023.
She is exceptionally well qualified academically. She obtained a bachelor's degree in physics from the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) in 1989, followed by a master's degree and a PhD in Energy Engineering, also from UNAM.
She undertook doctoral research at
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California, associated with the
University of California, Berkeley. She was also a contributor to the UN
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which jointly received the
2007 Nobel Peace Prize with Al Gore.
Her willingness to spend 21 hours in economy class is a conspicuous departure from the privileges normally associated with heads of state. It also reflects her political movement's commitment to austerity and its emphasis on identifying with ordinary Mexicans. It is therefore both a personal practice and a political statement.
What interests me particularly is that she has made commercial travel a regular practice rather than reserving it for occasional high-profile appearances.
I do, however, feel a little sorry for the officials accompanying President Sheinbaum. After spending some 21 hours cramped in economy class, they would probably have had to get down to work almost immediately upon arrival, with little opportunity to recover from the long journey. Shouldn't they be entitled to a little more comfort, if only to ensure that they are physically and mentally fresh enough to discharge their duties effectively?
After all, there is a difference between personal austerity and operational efficiency. A leader may choose to sacrifice her own comfort, but should she necessarily impose the same sacrifice on those working for her?
Of course, Donald Trump arrived in Air Force One, and Russian President Vladimir Putin in his dedicated presidential aircraft.
Even Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape appears to have chartered an Australian Bombardier executive jet to Shenzhen for the occasion. (What happened to his own government's Falcon 900EX?)
Joko Widodo (Jokowi) famously flew economy class shortly after becoming Indonesia's president in October 2014, but subsequently made extensive use of government VIP aircraft throughout his presidency (2014–2024).
However, it would be unfair to suggest that he abandoned economy travel only after becoming accustomed to presidential privileges. He was already using the presidential jet within days of taking office. His much-publicised economy flight to Singapore in November 2014 was to attend his son's graduation, a private family occasion.
In Jokowi's case, the economy flight was genuine, but it was never representative of how he generally travelled as president.
I remember Lee Kuan Yew, in his book From Third World to First: The Singapore Story, 1965–2000, writing about the extravagance of political leaders from countries that were still struggling economically.
Lee recalled attending international conferences where leaders from wealthy and poor countries alike arrived in special aircraft. He observed that it had become fashionable for leaders of the bigger Third World countries to travel in their own aircraft.
He specifically mentioned Kenya and Nigeria, whose presidents travelled in dedicated aircraft despite their countries' economic circumstances.
He then contrasted their behaviour with his own: "So I made a virtue of arriving by ordinary commercial aircraft"
Lee also recounted that Singapore's permanent representative at the United Nations explained that the poorer the country, the bigger the Cadillacs its leaders hired.
In a speech Lee delivered in 1996, preserved in Singapore's National Archives, he explained that suggestions to purchase a small jet for Singapore ministers were consistently rejected because doing so would create a culture of entitlement among public officials.
He even warned that an aircraft sitting idle might tempt officials to use it for weekend trips. His concern went beyond the purchase price. He feared the mentality that official privileges could cultivate throughout government.
The late Tan Sri Frank W. K. Tsao, of IMC fame, began to base himself in Singapore after leading a consortium of Hong Kong investors to develop Suntec City.
Tan Sri Tsao had substantial investments in Malaysia and flew to Kuala Lumpur frequently, especially after he built Menara IMC at Jalan Sultan Ismail.
He also flew economy class between Singapore and Kuala Lumpur.
I recall that a senior executive in his group had bought a business-class ticket for a flight from Singapore to Kuala Lumpur. On learning that the big boss was on the same flight, travelling economy, he decided to change to a later flight!
Tan Sri Tsao explained to me that the journey was less than an hour. What's the big deal?
I cannot quite remember who told me this next story, but it was about his experience with a fellow passenger on a flight from Kota Kinabalu to Kuala Lumpur.
He flew First Class on MAS (there was no Business Class categorisation in those days). The late Tan Sri Lau Gaik Poh, a tycoon with whom he was acquainted, flew Economy.
On arrival, Tan Sri Lau remarked to him, "We arrive at the same time!"
The subtlety is overwhelming!
Coming back to Air Force One, those accompanying Donald Trump included some of the richest men in America. Most of them probably have their own large private jets.
I do not know the seating configuration
in Air Force One. But having to squeeze into a shared aircraft, however
luxurious, must be quite an experience for these billionaires, let alone having
to exit through the rear door of the aircraft!
Perhaps even billionaires have to learn a little humility occasionally!
I received a little private tuition on this subject from the late Tan Sri Lim Goh Tong, my big boss at Genting.
On seeing that I was unable to squat comfortably with the construction workers at a worksite, he said: "Yu Bok, one must know how to squat with workers and sip champagne with the prime minister!"
I have never forgotten that lesson.
In the second half of the 1980s, rubber and palm oil prices were pretty bad. I was then with Guthrie, and I thought I should also play my part in saving costs.
On a trip to London, I volunteered to travel Economy and put up at a modest hotel
When he learnt of this, the late Tan Sri Rashdan Baba gently reminded me that I should observe a certain standard.
His message was clear. As an executive representing a major corporation, I was expected to uphold a certain standard commensurate with the organisation's standing.
It was not simply a matter of personal comfort or indulgence, but also of corporate image and the position one represented.
Two very different lessons from two highly accomplished men!
What then should we make of Claudia Sheinbaum's decision to fly economy class for 21 hours?
I admire her willingness to put aside the privileges of her office and travel like an ordinary citizen. Her academic credentials and political standing certainly do not require reinforcement through the trappings of presidential luxury.
But I am equally mindful of the lessons I learnt from Tan Sri Lim Goh Tong and Tan Sri Rashdan Baba.
There is a time to squat with workers and a time to drink champagne with the prime minister. There is also a time when the standing of an organisation or a country demands a certain level of protocol and representation.
The important thing is to know the difference.
I do not believe that a president must always fly economy class, any more than I believe that a president must always travel in a private jet. Security, logistics, efficiency and the demands of office are legitimate considerations.
What I find objectionable is the culture of entitlement that so easily creeps into positions of power, particularly in countries where millions of ordinary citizens are still struggling to make ends meet.
Lee Kuan Yew understood this very well. So did Tan Sri Frank Tsao, who saw little point in paying for Business Class on a flight lasting less than an hour.
Ultimately, it is not the class in which one travels that determines one's stature.
A truly accomplished leader should be
equally comfortable sitting among ordinary passengers, squatting with
construction workers, or sharing champagne with the most powerful people in the
world.
And above all, he or she should never confuse the privileges of office with personal greatness.










