Saturday, November 21, 2026

Mexico’s President Flew Economy!

Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico, travelling as an ordinary passenger on a commercial flight to China.



Claudia Sheinbaum, aged 64, travelled approximately 21 hours in economy class aboard a China Southern Airlines commercial flight, via Tijuana, to attend the APEC Summit in Shenzhen in November 2026.

Her journey became a sensation on Chinese social media, with many praising her apparent lack of pretension and willingness to travel alongside ordinary passengers.

Sheinbaum has been President of Mexico since October 2024.

For overseas trips, travelling on commercial airlines, including economy class, has been her usual practice, although not an absolute rule for all official travel.

There is one important qualification: she has acknowledged using Mexican military aircraft for some domestic trips, particularly when visiting several locations within a short period.

Her travel practices are also part of a broader tradition of government austerity promoted by her predecessor, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, who sold Mexico's presidential Boeing 787 in 2023.

She is exceptionally well qualified academically. She obtained a bachelor's degree in physics from the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) in 1989, followed by a master's degree and a PhD in Energy Engineering, also from UNAM.

She undertook doctoral research at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California, associated with the University of California, Berkeley. She was also a contributor to the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which jointly received the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize with Al Gore.

Her willingness to spend 21 hours in economy class is a conspicuous departure from the privileges normally associated with heads of state. It also reflects her political movement's commitment to austerity and its emphasis on identifying with ordinary Mexicans. It is therefore both a personal practice and a political statement.

What interests me particularly is that she has made commercial travel a regular practice rather than reserving it for occasional high-profile appearances.

I do, however, feel a little sorry for the officials accompanying President Sheinbaum. After spending some 21 hours cramped in economy class, they would probably have had to get down to work almost immediately upon arrival, with little opportunity to recover from the long journey. Shouldn't they be entitled to a little more comfort, if only to ensure that they are physically and mentally fresh enough to discharge their duties effectively?

After all, there is a difference between personal austerity and operational efficiency. A leader may choose to sacrifice her own comfort, but should she necessarily impose the same sacrifice on those working for her?

Of course, Donald Trump arrived in Air Force One, and Russian President Vladimir Putin in his dedicated presidential aircraft.

Even Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape appears to have chartered an Australian Bombardier executive jet to Shenzhen for the occasion. (What happened to his own government's Falcon 900EX?)

Joko Widodo (Jokowi) famously flew economy class shortly after becoming Indonesia's president in October 2014, but subsequently made extensive use of government VIP aircraft throughout his presidency (2014–2024).

However, it would be unfair to suggest that he abandoned economy travel only after becoming accustomed to presidential privileges. He was already using the presidential jet within days of taking office. His much-publicised economy flight to Singapore in November 2014 was to attend his son's graduation, a private family occasion.

In Jokowi's case, the economy flight was genuine, but it was never representative of how he generally travelled as president.

I remember Lee Kuan Yew, in his book From Third World to First: The Singapore Story, 1965–2000, writing about the extravagance of political leaders from countries that were still struggling economically.

Lee recalled attending international conferences where leaders from wealthy and poor countries alike arrived in special aircraft. He observed that it had become fashionable for leaders of the bigger Third World countries to travel in their own aircraft.

He specifically mentioned Kenya and Nigeria, whose presidents travelled in dedicated aircraft despite their countries' economic circumstances.

He then contrasted their behaviour with his own: "So I made a virtue of arriving by ordinary commercial aircraft"

Lee also recounted that Singapore's permanent representative at the United Nations explained that the poorer the country, the bigger the Cadillacs its leaders hired.

In a speech Lee delivered in 1996, preserved in Singapore's National Archives, he explained that suggestions to purchase a small jet for Singapore ministers were consistently rejected because doing so would create a culture of entitlement among public officials.

He even warned that an aircraft sitting idle might tempt officials to use it for weekend trips. His concern went beyond the purchase price. He feared the mentality that official privileges could cultivate throughout government.


In the Commercial World
The late Tan Sri Frank W. K. Tsao, of IMC fame, began to base himself in Singapore after leading a consortium of Hong Kong investors to develop Suntec City.

Tan Sri Tsao had substantial investments in Malaysia and flew to Kuala Lumpur frequently, especially after he built Menara IMC at Jalan Sultan Ismail.

He also flew economy class between Singapore and Kuala Lumpur.

I recall that a senior executive in his group had bought a business-class ticket for a flight from Singapore to Kuala Lumpur. On learning that the big boss was on the same flight, travelling economy, he decided to change to a later flight!

Tan Sri Tsao explained to me that the journey was less than an hour. What's the big deal?

I cannot quite remember who told me this next story, but it was about his experience with a fellow passenger on a flight from Kota Kinabalu to Kuala Lumpur.

He flew First Class on MAS (there was no Business Class categorisation in those days). The late Tan Sri Lau Gaik Poh, a tycoon with whom he was acquainted, flew Economy.

On arrival, Tan Sri Lau remarked to him, "We arrive at the same time!"

The subtlety is overwhelming!

Coming back to Air Force One, those accompanying Donald Trump included some of the richest men in America. Most of them probably have their own large private jets.

I do not know the seating configuration in Air Force One. But having to squeeze into a shared aircraft, however luxurious, must be quite an experience for these billionaires, let alone having to exit through the rear door of the aircraft!

Perhaps even billionaires have to learn a little humility occasionally!


Occasion, Occasion, Occasion
I received a little private tuition on this subject from the late Tan Sri Lim Goh Tong, my big boss at Genting.

On seeing that I was unable to squat comfortably with the construction workers at a worksite, he said: "Yu Bok, one must know how to squat with workers and sip champagne with the prime minister!"

I have never forgotten that lesson.

In the second half of the 1980s, rubber and palm oil prices were pretty bad. I was then with Guthrie, and I thought I should also play my part in saving costs.

On a trip to London, I volunteered to travel Economy and put up at a modest hotel

When he learnt of this, the late Tan Sri Rashdan Baba gently reminded me that I should observe a certain standard.

 "We are Guthrie," he said!

His message was clear. As an executive representing a major corporation, I was expected to uphold a certain standard commensurate with the organisation's standing.

It was not simply a matter of personal comfort or indulgence, but also of corporate image and the position one represented.

Two very different lessons from two highly accomplished men!


Conclusion
What then should we make of Claudia Sheinbaum's decision to fly economy class for 21 hours?

I admire her willingness to put aside the privileges of her office and travel like an ordinary citizen. Her academic credentials and political standing certainly do not require reinforcement through the trappings of presidential luxury.

But I am equally mindful of the lessons I learnt from Tan Sri Lim Goh Tong and Tan Sri Rashdan Baba.

There is a time to squat with workers and a time to drink champagne with the prime minister. There is also a time when the standing of an organisation or a country demands a certain level of protocol and representation.

The important thing is to know the difference.

I do not believe that a president must always fly economy class, any more than I believe that a president must always travel in a private jet. Security, logistics, efficiency and the demands of office are legitimate considerations.

What I find objectionable is the culture of entitlement that so easily creeps into positions of power, particularly in countries where millions of ordinary citizens are still struggling to make ends meet.

Lee Kuan Yew understood this very well. So did Tan Sri Frank Tsao, who saw little point in paying for Business Class on a flight lasting less than an hour.

Ultimately, it is not the class in which one travels that determines one's stature.

A truly accomplished leader should be equally comfortable sitting among ordinary passengers, squatting with construction workers, or sharing champagne with the most powerful people in the world.

And above all, he or she should never confuse the privileges of office with personal greatness.

 Occasion, occasion, occasion!

 

End

 

 


Friday, November 20, 2026

Trump’s Little Napoleons

 

Just hours after Trump met Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on 19 November 2026, the US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) voted to ban three major Chinese telecommunications companies – China Mobile, China Telecom and China Unicom – from directly accessing US telephone numbers.

Again, the stated justification was national security and the prevention of fraudulent automated telephone calls.

Although the vote had already been scheduled on 29 October, three weeks before the Shenzhen meeting, the timing could hardly have been more damaging to the spirit of the meeting.

The contradiction is even more glaring than it appears

According to the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ account of yesterday’s meeting, Xi specifically highlighted the positive results of China-US cooperation in combating telecommunications and online fraud and called for further cooperation based on mutual respect, fairness and reciprocity.

Both presidents also agreed to formulate an action plan for building a constructive relationship of strategic stability.

Yet, within hours, an American regulatory agency imposed another unilateral restriction in precisely the same area.

Are the little Napoleons undermining Trump?

There is an institutional problem in American governance. The FCC, the Commerce Department, the Treasury and other agencies exercise considerable regulatory powers under their respective mandates.

There are three possible explanations:

  • A lack of coordination between presidential diplomacy and regulatory agencies.
  • Institutional resistance to rapprochement with China.
  • A deliberate dual-track strategy of diplomatic engagement while maintaining technological and economic pressure on China.

I suspect it is a combination of all three. Trump has no eye for detail; he is basically an emperor with no clothes and does not quite realise how often his little Napoleons sabotage him. Just look at Marco Rubio’s expressionless face and Auntie Bessent’s incredulous gaze whenever Trump spoke.

Genuine security concerns certainly deserve attention, but the distinction between protecting national security and seeing ghosts is becoming increasingly blurred.

The credibility of American diplomacy ultimately depends not on what its president says overseas, but on what his administration does at home.

If Trump genuinely wants to build mutual trust with Xi, he must ensure that the actions of his own administration are consistent with the spirit of their understanding. Otherwise, the Chinese leadership has every reason to question the durability of American commitments.

Impact of the ban

It is understood that ordinary Chinese citizens should still be able to telephone people in the United States. The FCC decision prohibits the Chinese telecommunications companies from directly obtaining American telephone numbers, rather than prohibiting all telephone calls originating in China.

People in China should still be able to dial +1 followed by the American telephone number, with calls routed through authorised international telecommunications carriers.

The distinction is important:

  • Access to US telephone numbers: Chinese operators cannot directly obtain American telephone numbers to assign to their customers.
  • International telephone calls: Chinese customers can still call existing American telephone numbers through authorised networks.
  • Internet calls: WeChat voice and video calls should remain unaffected by this particular ban.

It might get worse

However, a more worrying development appears to be in the pipeline.

In April 2026, the FCC proposed a much broader ban prohibiting telecommunications carriers operating in the United States from interconnecting with designated Chinese operators.

Even USTelecom, the American telecommunications industry association, raised concerns about the proposal and its potential disruption to international communications.

If that broader ban is implemented, ordinary telephone calls between China and America could become considerably more complicated, expensive or unreliable.

And just recently, in the wake of Jensen Huang’s affair…

The latest American restrictions are considerably more far-reaching than the previous bans on semiconductor exports to China.

On 16 November – three days before Trump met Xi Jinping in Shenzhen – the US Department of Commerce announced a new set of restrictions. They came into effect on 19 November – the very day of the Trump–Xi meeting.

Washington is no longer merely restricting China’s ability to purchase advanced chips. It is now restricting China’s ability to use their computing power remotely, even when those chips are physically located in third countries.

1. Denial of remote computing services to China

Previously, Chinese companies unable to purchase advanced Nvidia chips could rent computing capacity from data centres overseas.

For example, a Chinese AI company could train its AI models using Nvidia GPUs installed in a data centre in Johor or Singapore without physically importing a single chip into China.

The new rules substantially restrict this arrangement.

Existing data centres providing computing services above the specified threshold to Chinese-headquartered companies have a 90-day grace period to obtain American authorisation if they wish to continue providing such services without facing further export restrictions.

2. Restrictions imposed on Malaysia and four other countries

The US now requires export licences for most transfers of advanced AI chips to or within:

  • Malaysia
  • Singapore
  • Indonesia
  • Thailand
  • Brazil

This has considerable implications for Malaysia’s ambitions to become a major regional data centre hub, particularly in Johor.

3. TSMC and Samsung manufacturing restrictions

On 19 November, it was reported that both TSMC and Samsung had suspended certain semiconductor shipments to Chinese customers.

Previously, Chinese companies could design their own advanced chips and engage overseas semiconductor foundries to manufacture them, subject to existing export controls.

The new American rules tighten the conditions under which these foundries can manufacture and supply advanced chips to Chinese customers when American technology is involved.

In other words, even Chinese-designed chips manufactured outside China can be subjected to American restrictions.

4. Denial of servicing and maintenance of chipmaking machinery

This is another particularly damaging aspect of American policy, although it predates this week’s restrictions.

Washington has been restricting certain services involving semiconductor manufacturing equipment already installed in China, including:

  • Maintenance and repairs.
  • Replacement parts.
  • Software and firmware upgrades.
  • Technical assistance from American engineers.
  • Installation and calibration of advanced machinery.

The US has also been pressing the Netherlands and Japan to tighten restrictions on semiconductor manufacturing equipment, including the servicing of certain machines supplied by the Dutch company ASML. This is not yet a blanket prohibition on servicing all existing machines in China.

The longer-term consequences

The American strategy increasingly appears to be:

If China cannot buy the chips, cannot manufacture them overseas, cannot readily service the machinery needed to make them domestically, and cannot even rent their computing capacity overseas, its technological advancement will be retarded.

Washington justifies this on national security grounds, but the restrictions have ramifications far beyond military applications.

The unintended consequences could be equally significant:

  • Accelerating Huawei’s Ascend AI chip development.
  • Accelerating SMIC’s domestic semiconductor manufacturing capabilities.
  • Stimulating indigenous Chinese semiconductor equipment and software industries.
  • Eventually depriving American technology companies of a substantial market.

Conclusion

These restrictions will certainly slow down China’s technological advancement in the short term; however, it will also further strengthen its long-term resolve to eliminate its dependence on American technology.

China knows these little Napoleons only too well, notwithstanding the fact that Xi indulged Trump and his hangers-on in Shenzhen.

That’s the way China conducts its diplomacy!

The West does not know what the Chinese are actually thinking and planning!

End

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Takht-i-Bahi Monastery - An Appeal for Support

I toured Northern Pakistan from 17 to 26 October 2026. The landscape was awesome – towering mountains everywhere, dramatic valleys and breathtaking scenery. The people were simple, warm and friendly, although the roads could be quite treacherous and many of the towns appeared rather basic.

What surprised me most, however, was the effort being made to preserve the country's Buddhist heritage. What a contrast with the Taliban's deliberate destruction of the great Buddhist statues in Afghanistan's Bamiyan Valley!

Pakistan has an extraordinarily rich Buddhist archaeological heritage. There are hundreds of documented Buddhist archaeological sites, and potentially thousands more if smaller ruins, stupas, rock carvings and yet-to-be-documented remains are included.

Our tour took us to several significant sites in Taxila in Punjab, the Swat Valley in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Mardan and Buner, and Gilgit-Baltistan. We also visited two museums, where I was particularly impressed by their collections of Gandharan Buddhist sculptures and artefacts. One museum displays a relic believed to be a tooth of the Buddha, reportedly one of only a few such relics surviving in the world today.

However, it was our visit to the Takht-i-Bahi Monastery that prompted me to write this message. There, we were received by the archaeological staff responsible for looking after the site, headed by a gentleman named Saifullah.

Takht-i-Bahi is one of the most remarkable Buddhist archaeological sites in South Asia. What makes it particularly special is its remarkably well-preserved monastic complex. Walking through its ruins, one can imagine not merely Buddhist worship, but also the everyday intellectual, communal and spiritual lives of monks nearly 2,000 years ago.

We were also told that the famous Chinese Buddhist monk and traveller Xuanzang (玄奘) had stayed there during his journey through the region.

With resident archaeologist Saifullah

I found Saifullah knowledgeable and passionate about the site. Our encounter left me with the impression that the monastery deserves much greater attention and support, not only from the Pakistani authorities but also from the international Buddhist and heritage communities.

It is, in my opinion, a place worthy of support. I can think of three practical ways in which we could contribute:

(a)  Support educational programmes – Help local communities, especially the younger generations, understand and appreciate the historical and cultural significance of the Buddhist relics in their own backyard.

(b)  Promote research and wider interest – Encourage greater research into Gandhara's historical importance and its connections with the spread of Buddhism along the Silk Road, particularly into China and the rest of East Asia. 

(c)  Improve facilities for the archaeological staff – Help provide more decent living and working quarters for the people who are actually looking after the site.

Takht-i-Bahi belongs not just to Pakistan, but to the shared heritage of humanity. Its preservation is important not only for Buddhists, but also for anyone interested in the history of civilisation, art, religion and the movement of ideas across Asia.

I came away from my visit with great admiration for the people looking after the site, and with the feeling that more could and should be done to support them.

Perhaps you may like to consider lending your support to one of the three areas I have mentioned, particularly the third proposition – improving the living and working quarters of the archaeological staff.

It need not be a large donation. Even a modest contribution could make a meaningful difference to the lives of these dedicated people.

Incidentally, I noticed that Thai visitors were among the most visible tourists at these Buddhist heritage sites. Thai International was also mentioned as one of the major sponsors supporting heritage-related activities in the region. It is heartening to see such interest from the wider Buddhist community.

I thought I would share these observations with you, in the hope that something worthwhile might come out of my visit. I would be happy to serve as a bridge between you and Saifullah. 

More information about the archaeological preservation efforts can be found in the link below.

I am not a Buddhist per se. My interest lies in supporting worthwhile causes that promote religious tolerance, mutual understanding and respect for our shared cultural heritage.

End 

Click here to open the link

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1VivGp1TMOxpD2kHBaRgdFfcpoSSJa6AO/view?usp=sharing

Sunday, November 8, 2026

“My Name Was Not on the Ballot”

 When asked to explain the Republicans’ crushing defeat in the November 2026 midterm elections, Donald Trump had a simple explanation: “I wasn't on the Ballot and if I was, we would have won in a LANDSLIDE!”

There is apparently no such word as “defeat” in Trump's vocabulary. It is always someone else's fault!

Remember his first term? When the writing was already on the wall that he had lost the 2020 presidential election, he went to extraordinary lengths to convince Americans, and indeed the whole world, that he was the real winner.

He claimed widespread electoral fraud without producing credible evidence sufficient to overturn the results. His campaign and allies launched more than 60 legal challenges, almost all unsuccessful. He personally pressured Georgia's Secretary of State to find another 11,780 votes, enough to reverse his loss there. His supporters and associates promoted alternative slates of electors, while he pressured Vice-President Mike Pence to reject the electoral votes when Congress met to certify the results.

The whole episode culminated in the storming of the Capitol on January 6, 2021. Even then, Trump was unwilling to concede that he had lost.

But lose he did!

Joe Biden then took over. Unfortunately, he was foolish enough not to take advantage of the very issues that had caused Trump's ouster. Instead, he doubled down on Trump's efforts to retard China's development.

The trouble was that China in the 2020s had already become a very different animal — economically, militarily, technologically and, most importantly, intellectually. It is this intellectual capacity, backed by a vast pool of scientists, engineers, researchers and entrepreneurs, that has been driving all the other fronts to greater heights.

Instead of recognising this new reality, Biden surrounded himself with a team of nincompoops — Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo, Trade Representative Katherine Tai and Ambassador to China Nicholas Burns — who helped lead him into blind alleys in his so-called war with China.

Under their watch, Washington imposed increasingly stringent restrictions on advanced semiconductor exports, pressured the Dutch and Japanese governments to restrict the supply of sophisticated chipmaking equipment, and raised tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles to an astonishing 100%.

Did they seriously believe such measures could stop a nation that possesses an enormous industrial base and an expanding pool of scientific talent from advancing? The Chinese simply have the intellectual capacity to find alternative solutions. Their determined efforts to develop a domestic semiconductor industry, in the face of American restrictions, are a case in point.

At best, these measures bought the Americans some time. At worst, they accelerated China's determination to replace American technologies and reduce its dependence on Western suppliers.

Biden's saving grace was his ability to consolidate the Five Eyes intelligence partnership, strengthen the Quad and advance AUKUS, particularly the defence cooperation between Australia, Britain and the United States.

But these arrangements were, in my view, half-baked instruments for containing China.

The Five Eyes is essentially an intelligence-sharing arrangement, not an economic development strategy. AUKUS promises nuclear-powered submarines for Australia, but the enormous costs, industrial limitations and long delivery schedules raise serious questions about its effectiveness. The Quad, meanwhile, is hardly a unified alliance. India has its own strategic interests and is certainly not going to become an American vassal.

Even America's closest allies are discovering that their economies remain deeply intertwined with China. Australia, for example, can hardly afford to abandon its enormous trading relationship with China simply to satisfy Washington's geopolitical ambitions.

In short, Washington has been assembling coalitions to constrain China without offering a convincing alternative to China's manufacturing strengths, technological advances and economic opportunities.

When Kamala Harris was named the Democratic presidential candidate in 2024, Trump gradually built up his momentum. Harris failed to connect sufficiently with the electorate. She was portrayed by her detractors as something of a dumb blonde, even though she was not blonde at all!

The rest is history.

However, this is where Eastern and Western political cultures differ greatly.

There is a Chinese expression, 卧薪尝胆 [wò xīn cháng dǎn], which describes the extraordinary humiliation and self-discipline a defeated ruler is prepared to endure while preparing to regain his strength. It comes from the story of King Goujian of Yue (approximately 496–465 BCE, during China's Spring and Autumn Period), who endured years of hardship before finally overcoming his adversary.

There was no such 卧薪尝胆 experience for Trump.

Instead of learning humility from his 2020 defeat, he treated his 2024 victory as a complete vindication of his first presidency. He became even more determined to rule like an emperor.

His word is supreme. Everyone must serve him — domestically as his minions and internationally as his vassals.

And like the emperor who did not realise he had no clothes on, Trump has become easy prey for those who understand how to manipulate his enormous ego.

Benjamin Netanyahu has demonstrated a remarkable ability to con Trump into supporting Israel's strategic agenda, particularly its confrontation with Iran. The Chinese leadership, on the other hand, has shown a far more sophisticated understanding of Trump. They know when to flatter him, when to accommodate him, and when to stand their ground.

One of the few Western exceptions, in my view, is Canada's Mark Carney, who seems to understand that dealing with Trump requires firmness, rather than endless flattery.

The rest of the Western political leadership — particularly those in Europe, Japan and Australia — have too often behaved like political idiots, seemingly unable to distinguish their countries' long-term interests from Washington's shifting demands.

But Don't Celebrate Yet…

Trump is not an ordinary man. He is a narcissist of the highest order.

Instead of eating humble pie following the Republicans' midterm humiliation, I suspect the results will only aggravate his anger and strengthen his determination to fight back.

After all, he has already convinced himself that the Republicans did not lose because of his policies. They lost because his name was not on the ballot!

Never mind that he had spent months telling voters to regard the midterm elections as though he were personally standing for election.

Pete Hegseth's defiant post-election performance outside the Pentagon, now ceremonially identified as the Department of War, was telling. He declared that the fight was far from over. I cannot imagine him making such a combative declaration without at least believing he had Trump's blessing.

Even more revealing is Trump's elevation of Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff.

Miller is no ordinary political operative. He is an ideological attack dog, far more calculating and, I suspect, considerably more dangerous than Hegseth. His elevation suggests that Trump is not preparing to accommodate the Democrats. He is preparing for confrontation.

Trump being Trump, personal glory, vengeance and political survival will continue to outweigh almost every other consideration.

And there is another consideration — personal enrichment. I suspect Trump will use whatever remains of his presidency to further enrich himself and his family. Indeed, the process is already well underway. Reuters has estimated that his family has made some US$2.3 billion from cryptocurrency ventures since his return to the White House. His family's expanding business interests, including dealings with foreign investors, raise serious questions about the extent to which the presidency has become entangled with private commercial interests. Trump, of course, insists that there is nothing wrong with these arrangements. But with his political future now severely constrained, I would not be surprised if he becomes even more determined to extract whatever personal benefits he can from his remaining time in office. After all, when has Trump ever been known to put public duty ahead of personal advantage?

He may become a lame-duck president at home, with the Democrats controlling both houses of Congress. His international standing may also be badly diminished. But he will fight them tooth and nail.

The Democrats can investigate his administration, frustrate his legislation and challenge his executive actions. Trump, in turn, can resort to presidential vetoes, executive powers and every political weapon at his disposal.

The result could be two years of extraordinary political paralysis and institutional warfare.

The country could go the way of Nero's Rome. So what, as far as Trump is concerned?

And then there is Iran.

Having already joined Israel in launching the war against Iran earlier this year, Trump may now be tempted to resume bombing the hell out of the country.

But this could become his international Waterloo.

The United States may still possess enormous military power, but it does not possess an unlimited capacity to sustain prolonged wars without serious economic, political and strategic consequences.

Its experience in Afghanistan and Iraq should have taught Washington a lesson or two. It can destroy military installations, overthrow governments and claim spectacular battlefield victories. But translating military superiority into lasting political success is another matter altogether.

Iran is no pushover. Its geographical position, ability to disrupt shipping through the Strait of Hormuz and capacity to impose costs on American interests throughout the region make any prolonged conflict extremely dangerous.

And the war has already contributed to rising energy costs and domestic dissatisfaction.

Netanyahu's own political future is now hanging in the balance. Following Israel's October 27 elections, President Isaac Herzog has chosen former military chief Gadi Eisenkot, rather than Netanyahu, to attempt to form the next government.

Netanyahu, who has demonstrated an extraordinary ability to survive political crises, may finally be approaching the end of his long tenure. Whether his successor will be less hawkish, particularly towards Iran, remains to be seen.

Trump may discover, too late, that bombing a country into submission is one thing; compelling it to accept an American political settlement is quite another.

Who Is Going to Laugh All the Way to the Bank?

Trump may well be one of them! He does not have to campaign anymore. He can now concentrate to make more billions for himself. 

But jokes aside, you might have guessed whom I have in mind. Nonetheless, let’s begin with those who certainly won’t be laughing…

The Europeans!

They have progressively relinquished much of their room for independent manoeuvre to Brussels and to a political establishment epitomised by Ursula von der Leyen — a real blonde, unlike Kamala Harris!

In my view, Europe has become a continent of great historical achievements but increasingly mediocre political leadership.

Germany, once the industrial powerhouse of Europe, has struggled with high energy costs, industrial stagnation and the competitive challenge from China. Its automobile manufacturers, long regarded as the world's finest, are now finding themselves challenged by Chinese electric vehicle producers.

France faces its own economic and political difficulties. Britain, having left the European Union, has hardly demonstrated that it possesses a coherent alternative strategy.

Instead of addressing their structural weaknesses, European leaders seem preoccupied with military expenditure, ideological posturing and following Washington's geopolitical agenda.

Europe is not without technological strengths or economic resources. But unless it rediscovers the ability to act independently, I fear it will continue to lose ground.

Japan's predicament is no less serious.

Its long economic decline began after the extraordinary expansion of the 1980s and the subsequent bursting of its asset bubble. The 1985 Plaza Accord was an important turning point in the pressures facing its export-led economy, although its subsequent stagnation also reflected domestic policy failures.

Japan is losing its formidability on the industrial and technological fronts. Its ageing population, rigid corporate culture, conservative institutions and resistance to immigration present formidable challenges as the world enters the AI era.

Its once-dominant consumer electronics industry has already lost considerable ground to competitors from South Korea and China. Its automobile industry now faces a similar challenge from the transition to electric vehicles.

Sanae Takaichi may have inherited the premiership, but I wonder how long she can survive Japan's deeply entrenched political and economic difficulties.

Meanwhile, back in America, Trump cannot constitutionally stand for a third elected presidential term in 2028.

Who will succeed him?

JD Vance? Marco Rubio? Or another of the Republican hopefuls?

I doubt that any of them can easily escape the enormous political baggage Trump will leave behind.

The Democrats won the midterm elections not because they possessed exceptionally inspiring leaders or brilliant policies. They had one major advantage — Donald Trump himself!

At present, they do not seem to have another Barack Obama who can electrify the electorate and articulate a compelling national vision.

Nonetheless, I suspect they will carry the 2028 presidential election, again thanks largely to Trump's recalcitrant mindset and the damage he will continue to inflict on the Republican Party.

But whoever wins, too much damage will already have been done to the American political psyche.

A nation that once prided itself on constitutional government, institutional checks and balances, and respect for electoral outcomes has become increasingly polarised, suspicious and consumed by internal hostility.

The decline, I fear, will continue.

And while America and its allies spend their energies quarrelling, sanctioning and confronting one another, China will continue to advance.

Living with a New Reality

George Yeo, Singapore's former foreign minister, is one of the few political thinkers whom I believe can speak with authority and intellectual honesty about the need for the world to recognise and live with a new reality.

It is a reality that many Western leaders still refuse to acknowledge.

China is NOT the evil empire that the West and the less discerning parts of the world have long sought to portray it as.

China has its shortcomings, as every great nation does. But it is foolish to interpret its rise entirely through the prism of Western fears, prejudices and historical experiences.

Of course, China also faces some serious domestic challenges — an ageing population, a troubled property sector, local government indebtedness and sluggish domestic consumption. Western analysts have been quick to seize upon these problems as evidence of China's impending decline. But are these necessarily signs of a nation in irreversible decline, or are they challenges that inevitably arise in the course of transforming a vast developing economy into an advanced industrial and technological powerhouse? The Chinese leadership is certainly not oblivious to these problems. It has acknowledged them and is taking steps to address them, although solutions will take time. What impresses me is China's capacity to think and plan in decades rather than electoral cycles. Nation-building is a long journey, and temporary setbacks should not be confused with the failure of that journey.

For centuries, Western powers expanded their influence through conquest, colonisation, unequal treaties and military intervention. They now seem incapable of imagining that a rising great power might pursue a different path.

Nor should the world continue to believe that the particular form of democracy practised in the United States and the West is the be-all and end-all panacea for every society.

Democracy is supposed to produce accountable government, sound policies and leaders who serve the interests of their people. When it produces political paralysis, endless confrontation, short-term populism and leaders such as Trump, surely, it is time to question whether the system is delivering what it promises.

China's experience suggests that there are other ways of organising a society to achieve development, technological progress and improvements in living standards.

The world should remove its blinkers.

Instead of devoting enormous resources to containing China, countries should ask themselves how they can cooperate with it, compete where necessary, and benefit from its enormous industrial and technological capabilities.

The coming AI era will transform almost every aspect of human activity — manufacturing, healthcare, education, agriculture, transport, scientific research and public administration.

China is particularly well positioned to exploit these developments because of its extensive manufacturing ecosystem, vast engineering workforce, infrastructure and capacity to translate technological advances into practical applications.

Those who continue to regard China merely as a geopolitical adversary risk being left behind.

Of course, countries must protect their sovereignty and national interests. Nobody should be expected to surrender these to China, America or anyone else.

But they should also understand that cooperation with China does not necessarily mean submission to China.

And they should stop assuming that China's rise must inevitably replicate the colonial expansion of the Western powers that followed Christopher Columbus's voyages more than five centuries ago.

The world has changed. China has changed.

The great irony is that the United States, which prides itself on innovation, dynamism and adaptability, now seems determined to resist a changing world rather than learn how to live in it.

Perhaps Trump's greatest contribution to history will not be making America great again, but accelerating the world's realisation that it can no longer depend on American leadership.

And China may well be the greatest beneficiary — not because Trump intended it, but because he simply cannot accept that the world has moved on.

End

Monday, November 2, 2026

How China Manages Nature — The Spirit of 愚公移山

I tend to reflect a great deal after seeing something remarkable. I consider myself a reasonably well-travelled person, and Pakistan has been just one of my many destinations. Yet it has continued to linger in my mind — its awesome landscape, the innocence and good looks of its children, the warmth of its people, their remarkable observance of hygiene despite difficult living conditions, their food, and the apparent honesty of their merchants.

But there is something I thought was missing among its people — the spirit of Yú Gōng (愚公).

Why do I say this?

It is in their rural roads!

I like to think of myself as a voluntary champion of Chinese thought. Perhaps I can help many in the West understand something of what drives the Chinese mind.

Let me begin with an idiom: 愚公移山 (Yú Gōng Yí Shān) — literally, "The Foolish Old Man Who Moves the Mountains."

The story comes from the ancient Chinese text Liezi (列子), traditionally associated with the philosopher Lie Yukou (列御寇).

An old man known as Yugong (愚公) lived facing two great mountains, Taihang (太行) and Wangwu (王屋), which obstructed his family's passage. Instead of resigning himself to going around them forever, he decided that he and his descendants would remove the mountains, basket by basket.

A supposedly clever old man, Zhisou (智叟), mocked him. How could an ageing man possibly move two mountains?

Yugong replied that although he would die, his sons would continue, then his grandsons, and generation after generation. The mountains, meanwhile, would not grow any larger. Eventually, therefore, they could be removed.

That is the wisdom of the story. It is not about brute strength, but determination, continuity across generations, and refusing to be intimidated by the scale of a task.

Mao Zedong made the expression especially famous in modern China. In 1945, he used it metaphorically to describe the two great "mountains" weighing upon China — imperialism and feudalism.

The Indus Civilisation, of which present-day Pakistan was a part, is older than China's civilisation in some respects. The ancient Silk Road also passed through the region. Yet much remains to be done to improve its infrastructure.

We Chinese have a saying: 要想富,先修路 — "If you want to become rich, build the roads first."

I do not mean to glorify the Chinese, but the following achievements certainly speak volumes about the spirit of 愚公移山. They represent undertakings too large for one generation, but achievable when successive generations continue the work.

A Less Yellow Yellow River
The Yellow River (黄河) is literally becoming less yellow.

Historically, it acquired its colour from the enormous quantities of fine loess soil washed down from the Loess Plateau, particularly in Shaanxi, Shanxi, Gansu and Inner Mongolia.

At its extreme, the river carried more than two billion tonnes of sediment annually. Recent studies suggest that sediment transport has fallen dramatically, by roughly 90% since the 1980s.

China attacked the problem at its source rather than merely dredging the river.

It undertook extensive revegetation of the Loess Plateau, converting steep agricultural land into grassland and forest through the Grain for Green programme (退耕还林还草). Hillsides were terraced to slow runoff, while tens of thousands of small check dams (淤地坝) were constructed across gullies to trap eroded soil before it could enter the river.

By 2019, some 58,800 check dams had been constructed.

Interestingly, when these dams fill with sediment, they often create flat, fertile land suitable for cultivation. Thus, the programme simultaneously reduces erosion, protects the Yellow River and creates farmland.

Large reservoirs such as Xiaolangdi also help regulate water and sediment flows.

What impresses me is the philosophy behind the undertaking. China recognised that the fundamental problem was not the river itself, but the landscape feeding sediment into it.

Instead of fighting the consequences endlessly, it sought to eliminate the causes.

There are still environmental challenges, and recent studies suggest that the decline in sediment has begun to level off in some stretches. Nevertheless, the transformation of the Loess Plateau remains one of China's remarkable environmental achievements.

It demonstrates what sustained intervention over several decades can accomplish.

The Three Gorges Dam
The Yangtze River was another source of recurring calamities for China.

Historically, devastating floods regularly struck the middle Yangtze, particularly around Jingjiang and Wuhan. The great floods of 1931, 1935 and 1954 caused enormous loss of life and destruction.

Even as recently as 1998, while the Three Gorges Dam was still under construction, catastrophic flooding claimed thousands of lives and caused economic losses estimated at RMB166 billion.

The Three Gorges project fundamentally changed China's ability to manage such floods.

Its reservoir has approximately 22.1 billion cubic metres of dedicated flood-control storage, allowing floodwaters to be held back and released gradually, greatly reducing the danger to downstream cities and farmland.

But flood control is only one of its contributions.

With an installed generating capacity of 22.5 gigawatts, Three Gorges produces roughly 90–100 billion kilowatt-hours of electricity annually.

It has also transformed navigation along the Yangtze. Before the project, shipping between the eastern seaboard and Chongqing was severely constrained by difficult river conditions. Today, enormous quantities of cargo move through the Three Gorges navigation complex, connecting inland western China to Shanghai and the sea.

The reservoir also releases water during dry periods to support agriculture, industry, drinking-water supplies and navigation.

There is no simple way to calculate its total economic contribution. Electricity revenues alone are substantial, but the value of preventing even one catastrophic flood could exceed many years of electricity earnings.

To me, its greatest achievement is the combination: a river that periodically threatened to devastate central China has become an infrastructure asset providing flood protection, electricity, inland navigation and strategic water storage.

Three Gorges represents the philosophy of managing an entire river basin rather than treating the river as an isolated engineering problem.

Dujiangyan (都江堰) — Ancient Chinese Wisdom

If Three Gorges represents the enormous scale of modern Chinese engineering, Dujiangyan represents something perhaps even more remarkable — the wisdom of ancient Chinese hydraulic engineers.

Built around 256 BC under the Qin official Li Bing (李冰) and his son, Dujiangyan is a 2,280-year-old river-control and irrigation system that continues to function today.

It was designed to tame the Min River (岷江), which rushes down from the mountains into the relatively flat Chengdu Plain, frequently causing floods while other areas suffered from inadequate irrigation.

Li Bing's solution consisted of three ingenious components:

  • Yuzui (鱼嘴), or Fish Mouth, which divides the river into two channels, directing water towards irrigation systems while allowing excess flows to continue downstream.
  • Feishayan (飞沙堰), or Flying Sand Weir, which releases excess water and sediment back into the main river.
  • Baopingkou (宝瓶口), or Bottle-Neck Channel, which regulates the quantity of water entering the Chengdu Plain.

The genius of Dujiangyan lies in its use of natural topography, river velocity and hydrology rather than simply overpowering the river with a massive barrier.

The system transformed the Chengdu Plain into one of China's most productive agricultural regions, earning Sichuan the name 天府之国 — "Land of Abundance."

The agricultural surplus also strengthened the Qin state, helping it eventually unify China in 221 BC.

What is extraordinary is that Dujiangyan never became merely an archaeological monument. More than two thousand years later, it continues to irrigate vast areas of farmland.

There is a wonderful ancient maxim associated with its maintenance:

深淘滩,低作堰 — "Dredge the riverbed deeply; keep the weir low."

In other words, do not simply keep raising barriers. Maintain the channels properly and allow nature to do much of the work.

That is more than two thousand years of systems engineering wisdom.

Three Gorges demonstrates how an enormous structure can control a river. Dujiangyan demonstrates how understanding a river allows us to work with nature rather than against it.

To me, that distinction is profound.

The Great Green Wall
Another remarkable undertaking is China's Three-North Shelterbelt Programme (三北防护林工程), popularly known as the Great Green Wall.

Started in 1978 and scheduled to continue until 2050, it stretches across northern China, covering a planned programme area exceeding four million square kilometres.

Its objective is to combat desertification, protect agricultural land and settlements, and reduce the devastating sandstorms that periodically affect northern China.

The programme is often described as planting trees across deserts. But that oversimplifies the undertaking.

China discovered through experience that planting trees indiscriminately in arid regions could be counterproductive. Unsuitable species often died, while others consumed scarce groundwater.

The strategy consequently evolved into something much more sophisticated:

Where rainfall permits, plant trees. Where it does not, use shrubs and grasses. Where even those cannot survive, stabilise the sand mechanically and preserve the existing desert ecosystem.

The programme combines vegetation restoration, grazing restrictions, agricultural shelterbelts and mechanical sand barriers.

One particularly impressive achievement came in November 2024, when China announced the completion of a continuous 3,046-kilometre sand-blocking belt around the Taklamakan Desert in Xinjiang.

The objective is not to turn the desert into a forest. It is to stabilise its margins, protect the surrounding oases and prevent shifting dunes from swallowing roads, railways, farmland and settlements.

China's statistics indicate substantial improvements in vegetation cover and reductions in desertified land, although drought, climate variability and ecological constraints remain serious challenges.

The Yellow River rehabilitation and the Great Green Wall are, in fact, complementary undertakings.

One prevents soil from being carried away by water; the other prevents it from being carried away by wind.

Both illustrate a common philosophy: rather than endlessly fighting nature's consequences, understand its processes and intervene at their sources.

Conclusion

The Three Gorges project was one of the most criticised undertakings in modern China, particularly by foreign observers, although there were also strong objections domestically.

The criticisms were not without substance.

More than a million people had to be resettled. Towns, villages, farmland and historical sites disappeared beneath the reservoir. Environmentalists expressed concerns about sedimentation, landslides, water pollution, fisheries and ecological disruption.

Engineers questioned the risks associated with a structure of unprecedented scale, while economists debated whether smaller dams might deliver similar benefits with fewer social and environmental consequences.

These were serious issues, and the costs should not be dismissed.

Yet the project has unquestionably delivered the principal benefits its advocates promised: enormous quantities of electricity, dramatically improved Yangtze navigation and, most importantly, substantially strengthened flood protection for the middle Yangtze.

China knew the social and environmental costs, but it also recognised the enormous strategic benefits the project could bring.

And isn't the bottom line obvious for all to see?

Looking across these undertakings, I see something distinctive in the Chinese philosophical mindset: the willingness to conceive and pursue projects not merely for a five-year political cycle, but across several generations.

The story of 愚公移山 is therefore not merely an ancient fable. It is a living philosophy.

It teaches that seemingly impossible tasks become possible through persistence, patience, accumulated knowledge and the willingness of successive generations to carry on what their predecessors began.

The Yellow River, Three Gorges, Dujiangyan and the Great Green Wall are examples of that philosophy in practice.

And why am I not particularly worried about ASML and the likes that seem to be holding back China to some extent today?

Because I know China will overcome!

End