Saturday, October 31, 2026

The Best of Pakistan-ness – Before Tourism Takes It Away

After posting my previous article, “Northern Pakistan – More Than Meets the Eye”, I was left with a lingering feeling that something was missing. There were a few important observations that I thought I should have included.

A Refreshing Lack of Unscrupulousness 

The first is the “innocence” of a child yet to be exposed to the ways of the world.

Tourism is still very much in its infancy in Pakistan, or at least northern Pakistan, since I have not visited the southern part of the country.

Few tourist spots had souvenir stalls, and even where they existed, the operators were not persistent in pushing their wares. Nor were the prices they quoted outrageous, as is often the case in our part of the world.

In short, they were not unscrupulous operators trying to make a killing from tourists' impulsive purchases.

In fact, I felt rather sorry for them. Tourist traffic was thin, and I wondered whether they could make a decent living from their businesses.

Everywhere I went, I tried to buy a thing or two, hoping to do my little bit to support local tourism.

I only hope that as tourism develops, these people will not lose their present innocence and become as commercially aggressive as their counterparts elsewhere.

The Fast-Ageing Phenomenon

Members of our tour group generally agreed that Pakistani children were remarkably good-looking, with sharp features, beautiful eyes and fair skin.

However, we also noticed that by the time many reached adulthood, they seemed to look much older than their actual age.

Their complexions appeared to have darkened under the intense ultraviolet radiation at high altitudes, while their skin had been roughened by hard work in the harsh outdoor conditions.

I suppose few could afford moisturisers or other skincare products. Neither do they enjoy the humidity that helps protect the skin in our tropical climate.

The combination of strong sunlight, dry air, harsh temperatures and demanding outdoor work must take its toll.

It was quite a contrast between the beautiful, youthful faces of the children and the weather-beaten appearances of many adults.

Their Curiosity and Friendliness

Another delightful observation was the curiosity and friendliness of the people.

They were not shy about approaching strangers to satisfy their curiosity. We were often asked where we came from, and their questions seemed to arise from genuine interest, without any apparent envy or ulterior motive.

On several occasions, we were invited to be photographed with local families, without any awkwardness.

At the China–Pakistan border control point, a group of young Pakistanis was delighted when I obliged their request to have photographs taken with me.

The same happened to my wife and me when we encountered a young family at the Centaurus Mall in Islamabad. They were just as delighted to have photographs taken with us.

There was something refreshingly spontaneous about these encounters. No commercial motive, no expectations, just a simple desire to connect with visitors from another country.


Conclusion
These may seem like small observations, but they left a lasting impression on me.

We often judge a country by its scenery, monuments, infrastructure, hotels and tourist attractions. Yet, ultimately, it is the people who leave the deepest impression.

Northern Pakistan certainly has its magnificent mountains, spectacular valleys and extraordinary landscapes. But what I found equally appealing was the unspoilt character of many of its people.

Of course, I am not suggesting that Pakistanis are uniquely innocent or that unscrupulous people do not exist there. I can only speak of what I personally experienced during our journey.

Tourism will undoubtedly bring much-needed employment, income and development to these remote communities. It would be unreasonable, even selfish, to wish that they remain isolated and economically disadvantaged merely to preserve their innocence for the enjoyment of tourists like us.

But development often comes at a price.

As more tourists arrive, commercialisation will inevitably follow. Souvenir stalls will multiply, prices will rise, and the friendly curiosity we encountered may gradually give way to the hard-headed calculations of the tourism trade.

It is a familiar story in many parts of the world.

I hope northern Pakistan can enjoy the economic benefits of tourism without losing too much of the warmth, simplicity and sincerity that make its people so endearing.

That, to me, is the best of Pakistan-ness — something worth preserving before tourism takes it away.

1 comment:

  1. 1. If Pakistan and Bangladesh had not split, their combined population would have been over 430 million. Indonesia's is 290 million and the Philippines is about 120 million.

    These numbers show they have human potential but not optimized for lack of better leadership, practical mass mindset and inbound investment capital.

    Their national models should therefore be some hybrid between that of Singapore and Turkey.

    2. When poor, accretive development is critical. One may take longer than others to reach the same level but better late than never.

    To stack progress year after year, good governance as a steady ship buffeted by waves and winds is the foundation for stability.

    Stability is needed to attract investment capital which chases risk-adjusted returns. WIth more funds, development programs can take shape and education levels can be lifted to add value to enterprise.

    3. Although Pakistan is poor, it hosts almost 2 million Afghan refugees for over 4 decades; its poor neighbor Iran hosts another 3.5 million.

    Pakistan also suffers a security problem. Since 2022, it has lost some 2,000 security personnel from attacks by separatists. The Talibans in land-locked Afghanistan are somehow influenced by India to disrupt Pakistan even while courting China for mining investments. Meanwhile China is worried the Ughur separatists trained in Afghanistan will reflux across the border.

    The whole situation is a messy cauldron of proxies. Pakistan needs more surveillance and Mossad-style embedded intel to take preemptive measures. Without better security, hard to sell tourism not to say manufacturing and other services.

    Pakistan and Afghanistan also need to modernize mass mindset with regards the brainpower and entrepreneurial energy of their women.

    To the extent religion can cleanse governance, it can moderate actions but anything beyond that becomes not only counterproductive to put food on table and roof over head but also derelict in the treatment of a fellow human being for just being born with XX chromosomes.

    4. It is tragic for humanity when people remain poor and their economy cannot grow properly inspite natural resources like minerals and land.

    Just as for Myanmar, stability is needed first then planners can blueprint and investors can part funds with more confidence. Without plans, the canvas gets chaotic and progress will be moot.

    The pristine child becoming the world-weary adult is an indictment against the vagaries of circumstance. Human potential can't then be fully realized and if that is not the universal objective of all life, what is?

    5. Anyways, if selling local products to tourists, it is surely absurd for the line of stalls to all sell the same products. (oops). Problem of supply chain. Develop a cottage industry.

    All implementors must practise MBWA. Management by walking around.

    6. Cleanliness and honesty are important for any service. Why not add more colors as well whether to the products or their stalls or the accoutrement of the locals? Eye-candies make for better memories. Drabness is dross.

    (sorry for this lacklustre post today - neuroendovascular impairment .....but intraorbital neurons still fire a bit)


    ReplyDelete